CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM
Memo Date: October 19, 2023
Agenda Date: October 24, 2023
Prepared By: Charlene Neuterman, Community Services Director
Through: Stockton Whitten, City Manager
Requested Action:
title
Adopt on SECOND READING of Ordinance 21-2023, a Land Development Code Amendment to Appendix A, Article XI, Section 22 of the Zoning Ordinance of the City of Cocoa to allow Large Scale Commercial/Mixed-Use Buildings on certain properties within the Cocoa Waterfront Overlay District.
End
body
BACKGROUND:
The applicant, City of Cocoa, is requesting an amendment to Land Development Code Appendix A, Article XI, Section 22 of the Zoning Ordinance of the City of Cocoa to allow for Commercial/Mixed Use-Large Buildings (CL) on certain properties within the Cocoa Waterfront Overlay District Regulating Plan. The subject parcels proposed to be designated CL, which share the address 430 Brevard Ave., are located at the NE corner of Brevard Ave. and Church St., and consist of the following Brevard County Parcel ID numbers:
• 24-36-33-39-B-7
• 24-36-33-39-B-8
• 24-36-33-39-B-11
The total acreage of the three parcels is 1.95 acres (collectively the “Subject Property”).
Future Land Use Designation: Current: Mixed-Use, MU
Zoning District: Current: Central Business District Cocoa Village Overlay, CBD-CVO
Existing Land Use: Mixed-Use Commercial Property, Multi-Tenant Office Building, Parking Lot
Waterfront Overlay Designation: Cocoa Village, CV
Council District: District 1 - Councilman Goins
Legal Ad Date: October 13, 2023
Overview of Surrounding Area:
|
|
Future Land Use Designations |
Zoning Districts |
Land Uses |
|
North |
MU, Mixed Use |
CBD-CVO, Central Business District Cocoa Village Overlay |
Retail Stores/Mixed-Use Commercial Property |
|
South |
MU, Mixed Use |
CBD-CVO, Central Business District Cocoa Village Overlay |
Restaurant/ Professional Building |
|
East |
INST, Institutional; MU, Mixed Use |
CBD, Central Business District |
Cocoa Waterfront Park |
|
West |
MU, Mixed Use |
CBD-CVO, Central Business District Cocoa Village Overlay |
Office Building/Retail Stores/Mixed-Use Commercial Property |
Background:
The proposed LDC amendment has been undertaken by the City of Cocoa at the request of Framework Group, LLC, who own the Subject Property noted above. The Planning and Zoning Board is required to make recommendations to the City Council regarding the proposed LDC amendments based on the criteria set forth in the Staff Analysis portion of this report.
Over the last several years, the City of Cocoa has created multiple policies that allow for unique and dense redevelopment opportunities with the City’s Community Redevelopment Area (CRA). The Mixed Use (MU), Future Land Use (FLU) Designation in the FLU Element of the City’s Comprehensive Plan states that the Mixed-Use land use category (MU FLU) “is intended to provide a mixture of residential, commercial, office, recreational and institutional uses along the major transportation corridors.” The majority of parcels within the City that are designated as MU are generally located adjacent to certain portions of SR 520, US 1, Brunson Blvd., King St., and the Cocoa Village Area, as more accurately shown on the attached FLU Map.
The density that is generally allowed within the MU FLU category is 25 du/acre and includes a bonus of up to 5 du/acre if residential housing units are developed as part of a vertical mixed-use project, per FLU Element Policy 1.1.2.6, which brings the max du/acre total to 30 du/acre.

The City also adopted policies that allow for “vertically mixed-use projects” to occur in very limited geographical areas, specifically on +/- 8.82 acres within the Cocoa Village and South-End Subdistricts to develop at densities of up to 125 du/acre, subject to and conditioned upon a development agreement approved at the discretion of the City Council after consideration of many factors as outlined in Policy 1.1.2.6 via Ordinance 07-2022. The map below shows the location of those +/- 8.82 acres.
In addition, five parcels, totaling +/- 5.72 acres, including the recently added 915 Florida Ave. property, have been designated with a commercial/mixed use large (CL) building type on the Cocoa Waterfront Overlay District Regulating Plan, which allows vertically mixed-use buildings constructed to a maximum of eight (8) stories in height, again subject to approval of a Development Agreement by the City Council.
As provided in Ordinance 07-2023, the very limited geographical areas deemed conditionally appropriate for the 125 du/acre program were, in part, chosen because they currently consist of older, but non-historic, buildings and vacant property identified in the Cocoa Community Redevelopment Area’s Redevelopment Plan as particular catalytic sites in the Cocoa Village area for redevelopment.
The section below will detail a new request that is a result of the above policy strategies undertaken by the City.
Request:
The Framework Group, LLC, as the owner of the Subject Property noted on page 1 of this staff report, has requested that the City designate the Subject Property as “Commercial/Mixed Use-Large Buildings”, or “CL”, on the Cocoa Waterfront Overlay District Regulating Plan. This would allow the subject property to be developed with a “vertically mixed-use building” at a maximum of eight (8) stories in height, subject to and conditioned upon City Council approval of a development agreement following consideration of multiple factors.
Modifying the Cocoa Waterfront Overlay District Regulating Plan to ‘CL’ on this subject property will in no way vest any entitlements on the subject property, including any information related to the conceptual development program.
If this item is approved, and to take advantage of the density programming allowed by the ‘CL’ designation, Framework Group would be required to enter into a Developer’s Agreement (‘DA’) with the City and have that Development Agreement approved by the City Council. While those initial discussions have occurred, and Framework Group has applied for said DA, the details of the DA is not up for discussion or vote as part of this request.
The following analysis provides for technical detail related to the request and the potential impact to City services.
I. Staff Analysis
Pursuant to Appendix A, Zoning, Article XXI, Amendment, Section 1(G)(2), the planning board shall consider and study:
a. The need and justification for the change.
b. The relationship of the proposed amendment to the purposes and objectives of the comprehensive planning program and to the comprehensive plan, with appropriate consideration as to whether the proposed change will further the purposes of this zoning code and other codes, regulations, and actions designed to implement the comprehensive plan.
a. Need and justification for the change
Staff Finding: Currently, the tallest building that could be constructed on the Subject Property is a five-story, “commercial/mixed-use medium” building type in accordance with the Cocoa Waterfront Overlay District Regulating Plan. In order to achieve the 125 du/acre density, the building heights associated with “commercial/mixed-use medium”, which has a 5-story max, would not generate the building intensities needed to maximum the density allowed by the FLU designation. The proposed change would maximize the densities allowed by the Comprehensive Plan and achieve the goals as further detailed below.
The Cocoa Redevelopment Agency (Cocoa CRA) continues to seek major redevelopment opportunities to revitalize the Cocoa Community Redevelopment Area.
The Long-Range Land Use Concept Plan details three Catalyst Mixed-Use Development Sites that have been identified as under utilized due to “outdated land use or building design” and provided the following guidance for the Subject Property specifically:
“430 Brevard Avenue (former Bank of America site): Determine status of potential time frame for redevelopment of the property and utilize former development studies as the basis for attracting developers to consider the parcel at the corner of Church Street and Brevard Avenue.”
The Subject Property is also noted as one of two “Medium Priority Projects” (Bank of America Site) as a Catalyst Mixed Use Redevelopment Site. Within the section describing Cocoa Village: “Significant redevelopment opportunities exist at several sites in the Village, including Bank of America, the former City Hall and Sun Trust Bank sites.” The proposed change also conforms with the following from the 2022 CRA Plan Update:
Goal III: Prevent the future occurrence of slum and blight.
Objective 1: As warranted, work with the Planning & Zoning staff, Planning and Zoning Board, and the City Council to revise the zoning classifications and the land development regulations within the redevelopment district based on the adopted overlay district to encourage a high degree of design and development standards for new construction and rehabilitation. Ensure that new development consists of appropriate land uses that will stabilize and enhance the overall quality of life of the area in order to achieve the desires and interests of its residents and property owners.
Goal IV: Encourage the acquisition, demolition, and reuse of those properties, which, by virtue of their location, condition, or value no longer function at their highest potential economic use and are currently depressing the value and viability of the uses in the near vicinity to them.
Objective 2: Encourage partnerships among the property owners, the private sector and the public sector in order to implement proposed redevelopment projects which will achieve public goals.
Goal V: Maintain the unique and positive character of the sub-districts while promoting economic vitality of each.
Objective 3: Make the redevelopment area competitive with major activity centers in Brevard County while maintaining its unique character.
Objective 4: Expand the economic base of the district retaining existing jobs while creating new diverse employment opportunities.
Objective 5: Create investment opportunities which will increase the tax base thereby generating additional revenues to finance actions which support CRA goals.
Goal VI: Market the CRA as a major destination point in the Central Florida Region.
Objective 5: Promote the redevelopment area as a unique center of activities that include a full range of commercial, office, institutional, community, residential, and neighborhood service facilities as well as the Cocoa Village Playhouse, arts and entertainment.
Goal VIII: Encourage innovation in land planning and site development techniques.
Objective 1: Work with the City and Planning and Zoning Board to include Mixed Use Developments within the Cocoa Overlay District, where appropriate.
Objective 2: Work with the City and Planning and Zoning Staff in the development of performance standards to be used within the CRA which will provide incentives and/or bonuses for developer proposals that provide for creative design and amenities.
Objective 3: Achieve the on-site mixing of residential and commercial uses in appropriate locations as determined by the community.
Objective 4: The CRA will promote mixed-use development patterns in new projects to provide greater diversity of use in close proximity of one another to promote reduced dependence on automobiles, and increased use of pedestrian and bicycle travel.
Goal XIII: Encourage and promote the provision of decent, safe, and sanitary housing to meet the needs of the present and future population of the CRA.
Objective 1: Identify and encourage areas where private interests can develop housing and the necessary support infrastructure in the CRA.
Objective 3: The City shall promote mixed-use developments that include provisions for a wide variety of housing types and price ranges.
The City Council will consider factors such as economic and social benefits to City and CRA, aesthetic quality and character, architectural design, physical and visual scale, compatibility with the Cocoa Village and South End when a particular development project is proposed and prior to approving a Development Agreement request to achieve the maximum of eight stories, in its sole discretion.
The proposed amendment is not contrary to the goals and objectives of the Waterfront Master Plan, Cocoa CRA Redevelopment Plan, or the Comprehensive Plan MU FLU policies. The proposed change allows for zoning bulk requirements that are more in line with the existing density policies which allow for up to 125 du/acre.
It should also be noted that the Subject Property is adjacent to the Waterfront Subdistrict of the Cocoa Waterfront Overlay District, which already allows for commercial mixed-use large building types with eight stories, without the need for a development agreement.
b. The relationship of the proposed amendment to the purposes and objectives of the comprehensive planning program and to the comprehensive plan, with appropriate consideration as to whether the proposed change will further the purposes of this zoning code and other codes, regulations, and actions designed to implement the comprehensive plan.
Staff Finding:
Since the zoning district will not change, there will be no conflict with the comprehensive plan. This amendment is consistent with the following policies:
Future Land Use Element, Policy 1.1.2.6 Mixed-Use (MU). The Mixed-Use land use category is intended to provide a mixture of residential, commercial, office, recreational and institutional uses along the major transportation corridors (such as SR 520 and US 1). Based on current land use trends, the City estimates that the mix of uses in the mixed-use category will be 50 percent residential and 50 percent non-residential. The Floor Area Ratio (FAR) measure shall not be applied to residential developments, or the residential portion of a mixed-use building or development.
Future Land Use Element, Objective 1.2.1: Smart Growth Principles. New development in the City shall incorporate “Smart Growth” principles that will lead to compact development standards as opposed to conventional development standards that encourage urban sprawl.
Future Land Use Element, Policy 1.2.1.6: New development, as well as infill development shall provide interconnected street grid networks, where feasible, to disperse traffic and encourage walkability. Developments may include a hierarchy of narrow streets, boulevards, and alleys; high quality pedestrian networks; designs that encourage a greater use of bicycles, rollerblades, scooters and walking as daily transportation; connectivity to public transit; and a land use mix that demonstrates reduced external trips by encouraging internal trips.
Future Land Use Element, Figure FLU-1
Housing Element, Goal 3.1: The City shall encourage and promote the provision of decent, safe, and sanitary housing to meet the needs of the present and future population of the City.
Objective 3.1.1, Housing Supply: Assist the private sector to create additional units and preserve existing units to satisfy the projected demand of dwelling units of various types, sizes, and costs which will be needed to house the City's anticipated population through the planning horizon.
Policy 3.1.1.1: The City’s Future Land Use Map shall provide adequate lands to accommodate the projected housing growth.
Policy 3.1.1.2: The City shall continue to provide land use designations and zoning districts on the Future Land Use and the Official Zoning Maps to ensure a variety of housing types including single family, duplex, and multifamily are allowed within the City.
Policy 3.1.1.6: The City shall promote mixed-use developments that include provisions for a wide variety of housing types and prices.
GOAL 3.7: The City shall promote opportunities for the creation of housing and infill development within the City.
Objective 3.7.1, Infill Development: The City shall continue to promote infill housing development by supporting alternative development standards where appropriate and feasible.
Staff recommends adoption of Ordinance 21-2023.
STRATEGIC PLAN CONNECTION:
N/A
BUDGETARY IMPACT:
Budgeted N/A
PREVIOUS ACTION:
October 4, 2023 - recommendation to Council for approval at P&Z meeting
October 10, 2023 - 1st reading approved by Council
RECOMMENDED MOTION:
Recommendation
Adopt on SECOND READING of Ordinance 21-2023, a Land Development Code Amendment to Appendix A, Article XI, Section 22 of the Zoning Ordinance of the City of Cocoa to allow Large Scale Commercial/Mixed-Use Buildings on certain properties within the Cocoa Waterfront Overlay District.